Product

Who it's for

Resources

Product

Who it's for

Resources

Product

Who it's for

Pricing

Resources

Sales Methods

More leads won't be enough: improve your closing rate first

Your close rate pays off more than lead volume. Why “we need more leads” hides the real problem, and how to spot the leaks first.

Gaultier Beauchesne

Co-founder & CEO @Eagr

More leads won't fix it: improve your sales close rate first

Table of Contents

🎧 Excerpt from the Eagr to sell podcast. Watch on YouTube.

Key Takeaways

  • “We need more leads” almost always points to the wrong problem.

  • When you analyze a pipeline, you mainly find quality leaks: leads that are never called back, an 80% drop-off between the first and second meeting, large closing rate disparities between sales reps.

  • Pouring more volume into a leaky pipe only makes the holes bigger.

  • Focus on closing and the discovery phase first. Add lead volume later.

  • The real issue is usually a skill, not a tool. Diagnose before you automate.

“We need more leads.”

Almost every founder says it when the numbers aren't there. And it targets the wrong issue.

Lyes Boukeroui diagnoses sales machines for scale-ups. He sums up this trap with a striking metaphor: pour water into a pipe full of holes, and all you will do is make the holes bigger.

Your closing rate is decided down there, downstream. Not by the volume of leads you pour in at the top.

Why “More Leads” Is a Misleading Reflex

Asking for more leads is comfortable.

It shifts the blame to an external cause—volume, the market—rather than the quality of execution. Saying “we don't have enough leads” hurts less than “we aren't good at closing.”

The numbers tell a different story.

The problem lies between the lead's arrival and the signing of the contract, in everything that leaks along the way. And the gap between sales reps is enormous.

Within the same team, with the exact same leads, the top closer sometimes signs two or three times more deals than the average. The market has nothing to do with it.

Lyes experienced this in the field, and here is what he discovers as soon as he dives into the numbers:

“We kept hearing 'we don't have enough leads, we don't have enough leads.' Then we would diagnose the pipeline and realize that it wasn't a volume problem, but a quality problem: leads that were never called back, an 80% drop-off between the first and second meeting for some reps. Artificially feeding a pipe that was already full of holes solved nothing.”

Lyes Boukeroui, RevOps Expert (ex-Uptoo)

The Leaky Pipe: Where Money Actually Escapes

Leaks are concentrated around a few recurring points, all related to lead management.

Spotting them shows you exactly where to take action.

  • Leads never contacted: not all leads receive a call, or not within the right timeframe.

  • Drop-off between the 1st and 2nd meeting: up to 80% loss for certain reps.

  • Closing rate disparities: conversion rates vary considerably from one rep to another.

  • Weak discovery: botched targeting and qualification, deals that drag on.

  • Wrong stakeholder: a second meeting conducted without the final decision-maker in the loop.

This last leak is often the most costly, and the most invisible.

Lyes eventually started refusing any second meeting without the final decision-maker, after noticing that he never closed any deals in that scenario. Gartner's data points in the same direction: B2B buying groups that reach consensus are 2.5 times more likely to describe their purchase as high-quality (Gartner). Sell without the decision-maker, and you allow that consensus to form without you.

A Concrete Example (Illustrative)

Let's take a team of 5 sales reps asking for more leads. They receive 1,000 leads per month.

Here is their current pipeline.

  • Leads received · Conversion rate: n/a · Volume: 1,000

  • Leads contacted on time · Conversion rate: 70% · Volume: 700

  • First meetings held · Conversion rate: 50% · Volume: 350

  • Second meetings booked · Conversion rate: 40% · Volume: 140

  • Contracts signed · Conversion rate: 30% · Volume: 42

42 deals per month.

Now, two options.

Option A, what the team is asking for: double the leads to 2,000. The pipeline leaks in the exact same way as before. Result: 84 deals, but the acquisition budget has also doubled.

Option B: keep 1,000 leads and fix two stages. Contact 90% of leads on time instead of 70%, and increase the conversion rate from the first to the second meeting from 40% to 55%.

  • Leads contacted · Before: 700 · After: 900

  • First meetings held · Before: 350 · After: 450

  • Second meetings booked · Before: 140 · After: 248

  • Contracts signed · Before: 42 · After: 74

74 deals, without spending a single extra dollar on acquisition.

You achieve a result close to Option A by developing skills rather than doubling the bill. The figures are illustrative, but the mechanism is real: every point gained in the middle of the pipeline counts more than an extra lead at the top.

The Right Order: Closing Rate First, Lead Generation Second

Plug the bottom of the pipe before opening the tap at the top.

It sounds counterintuitive, yet it works. The same number of well-managed leads delivers more than double the volume leaking from everywhere.

Here is how to diagnose, step by step, before launching a single campaign.

1. Map out your pipeline stages. Lead received, lead contacted on time, first meeting held, second meeting booked, contract signed. Five stages are enough to get started.

2. Measure the conversion rate for each of them. For each stage, divide the volume moving to the next stage by the incoming volume. You get a percentage per stage.

3. Do it per rep, not just globally. Averages hide discrepancies. Compare each rep's conversion rate from the first to the second meeting: that is where individual gaps appear.

4. Identify the biggest leak. The stage where you lose the most volume in absolute terms. Often discovery or closing, sometimes simply failing to contact leads on time.

5. Develop that specific skill. Not “sales” as a generic concept. The stage causing the problem, for the reps concerned.

6. Turn the upstream tap back on. Once the pipe is sealed, every additional lead actually converts.

Common Pitfalls During a Diagnosis

Four traps arise when trying to fix your closing rate.

Looking at team averages. A decent average closing rate can hide one rep at 8% and another at 40%. The average causes you to miss the real problem.

Jumping straight to a tool. “Automate opportunity generation for me” when the team already has enough. The shortest path is through the sales methodology, not yet another workflow.

Treating the symptom. You see the drop-off between the first and second meeting, so you add follow-up emails. But the root cause is upstream: a botched discovery, or a first meeting conducted without identifying who the real decision-maker is.

Trying to fix everything at once. You scatter your efforts across five stages and nothing changes. Pick the biggest leak, fix it, measure, and then move on to the next.

The Real Problem Is Usually a Skill, Not a Tool

When a sales ops tells you to “just automate this,” the shortest path is almost always through sales methodology.

Lyes sees this with his clients: they call him for an ops issue, and once he takes a step back, the real lever turns out to be skills. The team already has the right number of opportunities. They just need to improve at discovery and closing.

Maintain this diagnostic habit: observe, understand, act, measure, improve.

Don't jump straight into action just because a tool makes everything possible. Eagr pinpoints the exact moment each rep loses traction in the sales cycle, based on their actual calls, allowing you to replicate what your top closers already do across the rest of the team. Discover how Eagr diagnoses your calls.

FAQ

How do I know if my problem is volume or quality? Calculate your conversion rate at each pipeline stage. Are you losing many prospects between the first and second meeting? Are leads not all being contacted on time? Your problem is quality.

How do I calculate my closing rate accurately? Divide the number of signed contracts by the number of qualified opportunities over the same period. Calculate it per rep: the team average hides the real gaps.

What drop-off between the first and second meeting is considered abnormal? A drop-off of around 80% for certain reps is a major red flag. Compare your reps against one another. Large disparities point to a skill issue, and the market has nothing to do with it.

Which stage should I work on first? The one leaking the most in absolute terms, typically discovery or closing. Working on top-of-funnel is useless as long as the bottom is leaking.

Why does a second meeting without the final decision-maker lead to lost sales? Because you are relying on someone else to deliver your pitch who understands it less than you do, and the decision will be made without you. B2B buying groups that reach consensus are 2.5 times more likely to rate their purchase as high-quality, according to Gartner. Without the decision-maker in the loop, that consensus happens without you.

Should I stop lead generation entirely? No. It's a matter of sequencing. Seal the pipe first, increase the volume second. That way, every extra lead actually converts.

Sources

This article is adapted from an episode of the Eagr to sell podcast with Lyes Boukeroui. Watch the full episode on YouTube.

Further Reading

  • How to build a sales academy

  • Sales onboarding plan

  • Sales skills matrix

  • Continuous sales training

  • What is sales ops

  • Selling to the decision-maker

  • Sales techniques that work

  • Sales discovery methodology (BEBEDC)

  • Sales coaching: leveling up the whole team

  • Sales ramp-up: reducing the time to first deal

  • AI sales coach

  • Best sales coaching software 2026

  • Sales playbook: building it from real calls

  • The 5 questions top reps ask

  • Objections that truly kill a deal

  • Sales methodology: choosing, deploying, and replicating top performance

  • Sales discovery call: the framework that closes deals

  • Sales playbook: designing it from the real calls of your top performers

Want the same lookon your team?